Can you whip it both ways??

TAUTOG
Posts
522
Joined
1/27/2023
Location
Mohrsville, PA US
4/25/2024 8:11am
Richy wrote:
I'm in the 'no way' camp nowadays, used to be mildly to the left 😂 Same story with BMX, 180's/270's/360's, airing a quarter pipe, even just...

I'm in the 'no way' camp nowadays, used to be mildly to the left 😂

Same story with BMX, 180's/270's/360's, airing a quarter pipe, even just carving a bowl or something, to the left always felt more natural (initially wayyy more natural as a novice).

Probably a similar mental/physical hang up with how some skateboarders skate opposite.

was going to say the same thing with BMX

also and alley-oop on a quarter has got to be one of the coolest feelings ever

1
1
Ed_C29
Posts
21
Joined
10/29/2022
Location
Rubicon, WI US
4/25/2024 8:20am
Ed_C29 wrote:
I prefer leaning left, but can go the other way on good days. 

I prefer leaning left, but can go the other way on good days. 

Aztalan? 

Yes it is.

1
Tumic
Posts
1356
Joined
11/27/2012
Location
Sundsvall SE
4/25/2024 8:21am

With the risk of studworx calling me a liar i would say i can put it flat both ways.

But they won’t look the same when i do them and a left side whip will always feel more natural to me. 
 

I only scrub in one direction.

1
nrosso391
Posts
2501
Joined
2/8/2014
Location
Millville, MN US
Fantasy
2841st
4/25/2024 8:36am
Falcon wrote:
See? I don't think that thread settles it. I will give you the benefit that the voting (by erroneous, mislead cherubs) seems to favor the opposite...

See? I don't think that thread settles it. I will give you the benefit that the voting (by erroneous, mislead cherubs) seems to favor the opposite opinion to mine. Grinning

It would be interesting to put together an opinion profile that examines how many people subscribe to the same or different opinions and whether those line up in patterns. Such as, "Do people who think that this is whipping to the right believe that three jumps can be a quad and that the seat bounce is not real?"

Agree to disagree I guess. Knock yourself out. Make 3 entire threads about the same thing.

2

The Shop

enketchum
Posts
3858
Joined
2/6/2012
Location
Pasadena, CA US
4/25/2024 9:56am

where is the option for I can't whip it either way

Radical
Posts
2293
Joined
10/20/2012
Location
San Diego, CA US
Fantasy
2397th
4/26/2024 9:54am

I call what I do "mini scrubs". The bike's nowhere near flat, but it rotates and leans one direction, then I put it back before landing.

I think it does keep the bike a little lower.  I can do them just as well either direction.

I'm working on it!

toroP
Posts
4229
Joined
4/6/2009
Location
Cincinnati, OH US
4/26/2024 10:08am

Can’t whip, but I’ve mastered the cross-up.

Like 1970, baby

3
JoshyPoo312
Posts
165
Joined
12/27/2021
Location
Boise, ID US
Fantasy
282nd
4/26/2024 10:51am

Entirely dependent on terrain and corner/straight away before. There are some jumps that I could crank it one way but not even entertain the thought of going the other way. Contrary to that, there are jumps that I could whip either direction off of. 

For the fun of it... I refer to the whipping direction in correlation with the direction I lean. I.E. if I'm whipping to the left, the back end is out to my right. I see the argument for both, I don't think there is a correct answer... I'd rather go throw a fat one than argue about it anyhow. 

Here's one from last weekend at our RacerX Inter-Am Vintage event in Boise... '96 WR250. 

2
Falcon
Posts
10165
Joined
11/16/2011
Location
Menifee, CA US
Fantasy
913th
4/26/2024 12:07pm

^To be 100% honest, I can see both sides of that particular argument, too. I'm usually willing to fight to the death about something, but on this one, I'm only siding with the "direction you are turning" definition because that's what I've used to describe the action of laying the bike over. This was long before people started calling it a "whip" in MX parlance. 

5
JoshyPoo312
Posts
165
Joined
12/27/2021
Location
Boise, ID US
Fantasy
282nd
4/26/2024 12:20pm
Falcon wrote:
^To be 100% honest, I can see both sides of that particular argument, too. I'm usually willing to fight to the death about something, but on...

^To be 100% honest, I can see both sides of that particular argument, too. I'm usually willing to fight to the death about something, but on this one, I'm only siding with the "direction you are turning" definition because that's what I've used to describe the action of laying the bike over. This was long before people started calling it a "whip" in MX parlance. 

Bringing the attention to the front of the bike would add to that argument as well. The way the handlebars turn (or lean, at least) to initiate the whip would be consistent with this side of the argument. The only thing validating the opposite argument is the rear end. Either argument is true depending on these parameters... I went down the rabbit hole without intending to...Laughing

1
nrosso391
Posts
2501
Joined
2/8/2014
Location
Millville, MN US
Fantasy
2841st
4/26/2024 12:28pm

Its a "tail whip".. What part is confusing you guys? Its the side that the tail whips to...its literally in the name of the action you are performing. There is no front wheel or turning argument involved with the question "what side did you whip the tail?" I whipped it to the right. (so the rear end of the bike is WHIP'd out to the right). 

1
1
yz133rider
Posts
4517
Joined
8/1/2013
Location
Avondale, PA US
4/26/2024 12:40pm

Which way do you press the joy sticks on a video game to whip left? 

2
Richy
Posts
2957
Joined
7/18/2020
Location
UK GB
4/26/2024 12:43pm Edited Date/Time 4/26/2024 12:59pm
Falcon wrote:
^To be 100% honest, I can see both sides of that particular argument, too. I'm usually willing to fight to the death about something, but on...

^To be 100% honest, I can see both sides of that particular argument, too. I'm usually willing to fight to the death about something, but on this one, I'm only siding with the "direction you are turning" definition because that's what I've used to describe the action of laying the bike over. This was long before people started calling it a "whip" in MX parlance. 

I go with that train of thought as well (I don't see how anyone wouldn't, but I appreciate we're all different) as if you turn the bars left, you turn left. If you are in a corner, turn left, give it the berries, the back end steps out to the right, you are still turning left (and hopefully that continues until the end of the corner).

Edit. Continue that whip until it's a 180 or 360 and it answers the question categorically 👍

1
zehn
Posts
7294
Joined
1/15/2013
Location
Anchorage, AK US
4/26/2024 12:44pm Edited Date/Time 4/26/2024 1:22pm

So if you’re carving up the face of the jump to the right (initiating a right turn) you’re actually whipping to the left? Pinch

I’ve always referred to the direction the front of the bike goes. Front goes right, bike leans to the right and rotates clockwise, rider is hanging off the right side of the bike = whipping or scrubbing to the right. The back end of the bike just follows what the rest of the bike is doing.
 

Everything involved with whipping to the left as some would say involves a rightward motion and a clockwise rotation 

edit: switched up CW and CCW

1
Gworm
Posts
1670
Joined
4/5/2017
Location
Monett, MO US
4/26/2024 12:48pm
Entirely dependent on terrain and corner/straight away before. There are some jumps that I could crank it one way but not even entertain the thought of...

Entirely dependent on terrain and corner/straight away before. There are some jumps that I could crank it one way but not even entertain the thought of going the other way. Contrary to that, there are jumps that I could whip either direction off of. 

For the fun of it... I refer to the whipping direction in correlation with the direction I lean. I.E. if I'm whipping to the left, the back end is out to my right. I see the argument for both, I don't think there is a correct answer... I'd rather go throw a fat one than argue about it anyhow. 

Here's one from last weekend at our RacerX Inter-Am Vintage event in Boise... '96 WR250. 

I’m not judging, but I don’t think I’ve ever seen anyone scrub with a kickstand. 
 

Good form, though. 

4
nrosso391
Posts
2501
Joined
2/8/2014
Location
Millville, MN US
Fantasy
2841st
4/26/2024 12:54pm
zehn wrote:
So if you’re carving up the face of the jump to the right (initiating a right turn) you’re actually whipping to the left?  I’ve always referred...

So if you’re carving up the face of the jump to the right (initiating a right turn) you’re actually whipping to the left? Pinch

I’ve always referred to the direction the front of the bike goes. Front goes right, bike leans to the right and rotates clockwise, rider is hanging off the right side of the bike = whipping or scrubbing to the right. The back end of the bike just follows what the rest of the bike is doing.
 

Everything involved with whipping to the left as some would say involves a rightward motion and a clockwise rotation 

edit: switched up CW and CCW

I think you got your clockwise and counterclockwise's mixed up. None of that first counterclockwise sentence makes sense.  
You said:
-Front goes right                     (that's clockwise, not counter-clockwise)
-bike leans to the right
-and rotates counterclockwise, (no its clockwise... are you doing a barrel roll? 
-rider is hanging off the right side of the bike = whipping or scrubbing to the right.

1
zehn
Posts
7294
Joined
1/15/2013
Location
Anchorage, AK US
4/26/2024 1:22pm
zehn wrote:
So if you’re carving up the face of the jump to the right (initiating a right turn) you’re actually whipping to the left?  I’ve always referred...

So if you’re carving up the face of the jump to the right (initiating a right turn) you’re actually whipping to the left? Pinch

I’ve always referred to the direction the front of the bike goes. Front goes right, bike leans to the right and rotates clockwise, rider is hanging off the right side of the bike = whipping or scrubbing to the right. The back end of the bike just follows what the rest of the bike is doing.
 

Everything involved with whipping to the left as some would say involves a rightward motion and a clockwise rotation 

edit: switched up CW and CCW

nrosso391 wrote:
I think you got your clockwise and counterclockwise's mixed up. None of that first counterclockwise sentence makes sense.   You said: -Front goes right       ...

I think you got your clockwise and counterclockwise's mixed up. None of that first counterclockwise sentence makes sense.  
You said:
-Front goes right                     (that's clockwise, not counter-clockwise)
-bike leans to the right
-and rotates counterclockwise, (no its clockwise... are you doing a barrel roll? 
-rider is hanging off the right side of the bike = whipping or scrubbing to the right.

I did and fixed it 

4/26/2024 1:28pm
Tumic wrote:
With the risk of studworx calling me a liar i would say i can put it flat both ways. But they won’t look the same when...

With the risk of studworx calling me a liar i would say i can put it flat both ways.

But they won’t look the same when i do them and a left side whip will always feel more natural to me. 
 

I only scrub in one direction.

Sick!

Radical
Posts
2293
Joined
10/20/2012
Location
San Diego, CA US
Fantasy
2397th
4/26/2024 4:38pm
nrosso391 wrote:
Its a "tail whip".. What part is confusing you guys? Its the side that the tail whips to...its literally in the name of the action you...

Its a "tail whip".. What part is confusing you guys? Its the side that the tail whips to...its literally in the name of the action you are performing. There is no front wheel or turning argument involved with the question "what side did you whip the tail?" I whipped it to the right. (so the rear end of the bike is WHIP'd out to the right). 

I get it. It makes sense that it's a tail whip, so the direction of the tail determines the direction of the whip. Whip the tail to the right, it's a right whip.  But, what's confusing is that doing almost the same exact action in a scrub, it's a left scrub.  I can't imagine calling a scrub to the left a right scrub.  It's not a tail scrub.

NotCore
Posts
610
Joined
8/9/2011
Location
Alpharetta, GA US
4/26/2024 5:24pm
nrosso391 wrote:
Its a "tail whip".. What part is confusing you guys? Its the side that the tail whips to...its literally in the name of the action you...

Its a "tail whip".. What part is confusing you guys? Its the side that the tail whips to...its literally in the name of the action you are performing. There is no front wheel or turning argument involved with the question "what side did you whip the tail?" I whipped it to the right. (so the rear end of the bike is WHIP'd out to the right). 

Should we have the 'Roost' vs. 'Rooster Tail' discussion in parallel here, or start a separate thread?

bvm111
Posts
9354
Joined
7/1/2008
Location
Las Vegas, NV US
4/26/2024 7:43pm

my butt whips go in either direction 😂

reded301
Posts
268
Joined
8/4/2021
Location
KC, KS US
4/27/2024 5:36am

I don’t know whether it’s called left or right (leaning left with the ass swinging to the right) but I could lay em down pretty decent back in my day on the right jump. Never could get comfortable going the other way.

2
Falcon
Posts
10165
Joined
11/16/2011
Location
Menifee, CA US
Fantasy
913th
4/29/2024 4:09pm

Back in my day, we called it a tabletop. As in, lay the bike over flat like the top of a table. You would definitely name that trick like the direction your bike is turning.
When riders started really throwing the rear end out, I think it started the confusion. We're talking about the difference between roll (tabletop) and yaw (whip).

Do you guys who call it a "tailwhip" picture this trick more like a BMX tailwhip, wherein you are not leaning the bike sideways much or at all? That makes more sense to me if you're saying rear wheel to the right = whip to the right.

Post a reply to: Can you whip it both ways??

The Latest